Tuesday, August 07, 2007
Piperton: A Town Build On Speed Traps And Land Grabs
The appellation is particularly ironic in light of all the media coverage about town officials’ concerns about growth issues and future population growth pressures. It’s particularly ironic considering that the hamlet, nestled on the western border of Fayette County and snuggled up against Collierville sees that $500 million incentive for sprawl – Tennessee Highway 385 – as a godsend, dumping traffic and thousands of new residents into its borders.
While the town’s elected officials and city manager talk eloquently about smart growth, sustainable developments and the like, dozens of new $500,000 houses are sprouting up in areas that were crop fields only a few years ago. Most of these homes are located on two-lane rural roads off the primary artery through the town – U.S. Highway 57.
Speed Trap
Strangely, it seems like the more that Piperton tries to act like a real city, it’s apparently not mature enough to tackle its well-deserved reputation as a speed trap.
Although Highway 57 is more or less has the major gravitational pull for the town, incredibly, the town has gone to great lengths to annex – thanks to the largely impotent urban growth boundary laws of Tennessee – the land on which U.S. Highway 72 is located between Collierville and the Mississippi state line. No one familiar with the area would even suspect that Piperton could be in charge there, because it’s so removed from the town itself.
And while city and county officials try to argue that Piperton is not a speed trap, the only purpose of this annexation appears to be an added opportunity to lower the speed limit below all reasonable levels and hand out tickets to as many drivers as possible.
Paying For Piperton
Already, the town cops are known for their relentless work to hit their quota of speeding tickets, but in extending its reach to Highway 72, it becomes clear that the town’s finances must be built on speeding tickets.
In a creative attempt to justify the speed traps, Fayette County General Sessions Judge Mike Whitaker called it a highly effective deterrent to crime. Apparently, in the judge’s understanding of the criminal element, people bent on committing crime are scared to get caught speeding through Piperton.
In other words, in order to catch a handful of people, if any, speeding away from crimes in Fayette County and rushing back to that hotbed of crime, Shelby County, Piperton justifies stopping thousands of people a year who have no more evil intent than in getting to Rossville.
Freaking
It’s the town equivalent of making all of us take off our shoes at the airport because of one shoe bomber.
Meanwhile, Piperton and Fayette County officials proudly claim that the motorists’ harassment has in fact reduced the crime rate for the town, dropping it from 1,517 per 100,000 in 2000 and 1,415 in 2006.
It’s one of those statistics thrown out to back up an opinion you already have. The drop in the crime rate in the town isn’t the result of this special brand of traffic enforcement. More to the point, it’s the result of the increased population which drives the rate downward.
In addition to the traffic code, the mayor might give new policeman copies of Freakonomics.
It’s Not About Services
These same city officials predicted that the population of Piperton would reach 11,000 by 2010. That’ll require an awful lot of growth in the next three years. Population today is estimated to be 959. In other words, all of this heavy coverage by The Commercial Appeal is generated by a growth of about 400 people since 2000.
Recent data shows approval of permits for 21 buildings averaging $397,600 in 2005 and 35 buildings averaging $302,000 in 2004.
All in all, the growth of Piperton remains somewhat baffling in light of the overall poor state of public services in Fayette County - the lack of sewerage facilities, the problems of its public schools, the lack of emergency services like ambulances, and erratic fire protection.
Land Grab
This lack of quality public services doesn’t dampen Piperton’s ambitions, as it announces plans to pursue 14,000 more acres as part of its urban growth boundary, increasing its current annexation area from 14,404 acres to 24,870 acres.
The land grab by Piperton, and mimicked by Gallaway and Oakland, is aimed at gobbling up the land in Fayette County around Highway 385 and more to the point, gobbling up its expected tax revenues. It may not be easy, because Fayette County was one of the last counties in Tennessee to reach agreement on the growth boundaries required by Tennessee Growth Policy Act, Public Chapter 1101, Acts of 1998, and it didn’t happen until arbitration took place.
Regardless of the outcome, all of this maneuvering makes a mockery of the intent of the Growth Policy Act, which seems to have been a law passed mainly as a safety valve for the political pressure building on the Tennessee Legislature at that time. And as happens so often, once the immediate crisis passed, there really wasn’t anybody in state government paying any special attention to the kinds of urban growth boundaries that could contribute to smart growth in our state.
Sunday, August 05, 2007
Memphis City Schools' Plan Falls Short
It’s the Academic Affairs Department’s plan to spend $42 million in new state funds, and it does in fact feel much more like a proposal to spend money than a strategic approach to transform high priority schools threatened with state takeover.
In truth, the title reveals more than just the purpose of the plan. It also reveals something about the culture of Memphis City Schools, which lies at the heart of so many of its challenges.
One From Column A
Sitting in a meeting of high-level administrators putting the elements of the plan together, it’s telling that no one suggested a more inspiring, more uplifting name for the plan – something that suggests a commitment to innovation or to finding the levers for fundamental change in the district.
But the name of the proposal is just an indication of more substantive problems. More to the point, the “proposal for expenditures of additional state revenue” seems little more than a grab bag of every one’s favorite ideas with the objective of spending down the state’s money rather than creating the kinds of innovation needed in Memphis City Schools.
It had the expected impact in the governor’s office where it was seen as “more of the same” and as an indication of the district’s lack of understanding about the seriousness of the challenge facing Memphis City Schools as it relates to the 17 schools. It showed a lack of commitment to “doing what’s really needed” to turn things around, said one state official.
Group Think
Perhaps, the plan was just an unfortunate product of the kind of “group think” that often takes place in bureaucracies, but it’s hard to escape the conclusion that it’s similar to several programs and policies advanced in recent years that come from the district’s top-down approach.
While there are many reasons to praise Supt. Carol Johnson, she seemed to be a prisoner of a tightly-knit coterie of advisers who kept the circle small and the input from the outside smaller. It’s the kind of control and command style of management that marginalizes innovators in the district’s schools and makes it even more difficult to stimulate the kinds of bottom-up solutions that are truly needed.
In Memphis City Schools’ plan, it sets out “three main messages” that are in truth rather pedestrian - “intensive support for schools on probation, improve teaching and support for teachers and invest in academic and student support programs.” In other words, when it was read 210 miles to the east in Nashville, state officials read it as something that could have been written anytime in the past four years and lacked the sense of urgency or new thinking that’s demanded by the current crisis.
Something Outside The Norm
So, what dramatic approach is needed to turn around the 17 high priority schools around? Here’s what Memphis City Schools’ plan said: “Ongoing and focused professional development, modeling of effective teaching and assessment practices; ongoing professional collaboration; effective communication between school staff, parents and students; and visible tracking of student progress on a frequent and regular basis.”
While all are worthy objectives, they are read by education officials as warmed-over platitudes, but more to the point, they are read as givens for a major school districts, the kinds of things that should be taking place as part of its regular course of business.
Then, as if to punctuate the bureaucratic response to the problems of specific schools and their individual challenges and specific needs, the plan then essentially treats all schools the same.
Threadbare
Rather than giving each school the flexibility to customize its own strategies, the district’s plan talks about adding FTEs for this purpose or that purpose (down to the detail of one clerical position for the support team), performance-based incentives, lower student/teacher ratios for English as a Second Language (ESL), planning grants for schools interested in becoming charter schools, laptop computers, and adding 30 minutes to each school day.
All in all, it’s a collection of deserving ideas, but it lacks any sense that it is a real program of change or a real strategic approach pursuing a coordinated, interconnected philosophy for transforming these schools. There’s no feeling that there is a strategic thread holding it all together or that a specific outcome is being south.
While the bureaucrats of the Tennessee Department of Education normally tend toward the same sort of incremental thinking, these are not normal days. DOE officials only reluctantly become more forceful in exercising their power over the high-priority schools in Memphis, after years of doing all that they could to reduce their numbers and the scope of the “Memphis problem,” as it is called.
Something Different
But time has run out, and DOE is directed by a governor who never has to run for reelection again. As a result, there is a new sense of urgency communicated from Governor Phil Bredesen to his DOE minions, and impressed by the governor’s personal interest and his unyielding rhetoric, even DOE is looking for something more these days than the plan submitted by Memphis City Schools.
Reading the “Proposal for Expenditure of Additional State Revenue,” it’s hard not to wonder why local and state educational bureaucrats even feel the need to define strategies now.
How about trying something really revolutionary? Appoint the smartest, most innovative principals - with strong leadership skills - to each of the 17 schools, give them X amount of money and give each of them 90 days to develop a plan tailored for that specific school. These principals need to be the kind of leaders who can work with the neighborhood and parents to identify the needs that characterize that specific school and then individualize the tactical responses based on those needs.
The Real Change
Rather than treat the 17 schools as a monolithic group, this approach recognizes the fundamental truth about them – every one of them is different, with different challenges and with different strengths to exploit.
These are revolutionary times for public education. Around the country, districts are experimenting with exciting new approaches and new programs with promising results.
None of that energy is captured in the plan of Memphis City Schools nor is there any hint that it plans to joint the ranks of the nationally known districts that are well-known for their ambitions, their creativity, their virtuosity and their innovation.
In the end, that’s got to be changed before the 17 schools can be.
Friday, August 03, 2007
This Week On Smart City: The Biological City
Cities are like elephants. They get more economical with size. That's the conclusion of Dr. Geoffrey West, president of the Santa Fe Institute. Together with ecologist Jim Brown of the University of New Mexico, he is producing important new insights on how cities grow, why they fade, and what we can do about it.
Also with us is Denise Nunes to talk about her recent experiences as a volunteer reconstructing devastated homes in New Orleans' Lower Ninth Ward. Denise is a Williams College graduate and a native of Evanston, Illinois.
Smart City is a syndicated, weekly hour-long public radio talk show that takes an in-depth look at urban life: the people, places, ideas and trends that affect us all. Host Carol Coletta talks with national and international public policy experts, economists, business leaders, artists, developers, planners and others on the pulse of city life for a penetrating discussion on urban issues.In Memphis,Smart City is broadcast on WKNO FM, 91.1, at 9 a.m. Sundays. It is also webcast and podcast at the Smart City website, which also has a listing of broadcast times in other cities and the sign up for a weekly newsletter.
Thursday, August 02, 2007
Shelby County High School Attendance Zones
County Schools Get "F" In Federal Court Test About Its Fairness
She criticized the county school district for not taking race into consideration when it created its school attendance zones.
The truth is: That’s exactly what Shelby County Schools did, and that’s why, on balance, her ruling last week was the right one.
Solomon
Judge Donald, meting out the judicial equivalent of “half a loaf is better than none,” refused to dissolve the 44-year-old desegregation order for Shelby County Schools but approved this year’s attendance zones.
Typically, the county schools board members, particularly the master of the disingenuous justification, Chairman David Pickler, now seem as willing to accept responsibility for the consequences of their actions as Paris Hilton.
In the face of a noticeably stern judicial rebuff, county school officials trotted out their favorite, old rhetorical warhorses. Achieving racial balance would mean busing students, breaking up neighborhood schools and costing the district extra money, they warned.
Heckuva Job, Brownie
Superintendent Bobby Webb, who essentially acts as lackey to the board’s micro-management, said: “It’s a heck of a dilemma for me.”
Well, too bad. If you don’t want someone to shoot you, you really shouldn’t hand him a loaded pistol.
The loaded pistol for the county schools – and poster child for its racially-conscious decisions – ended up being Southwind High School. That’s why if county school officials want to see who’s responsible for this dilemma, they need only to look in the mirror. All it really would have taken to avoid the current dilemma was to make smarter decisions about the location of new county schools.
Self-fulfilling Prophecy
In the wake of the ruling, the county system also mounted one of its favorites – a disinformation campaign. Mr. Webb said that 95 percent of the people in the southeast area are African-Americans, suggesting that because of that fact the Southwind High School would of course be predominantly black.
To suggest that southeast Shelby County is 95 percent African-American is spin at best and a lie at worst. That’s because Mr. Webb’s statement is based conveniently on the county district’s own opinion of what constitutes southeast Shelby County.
In the world of county schools, southeast Shelby County mysteriously stops when it reached Hacks Cross Road, which forms the easternmost border for the attendance zone for Southwind High Schools. What the superintendent really is saying is: “When we count the African-American students, we’re only counting kids south of Lowrance and west of Hacks Cross. My gosh, it’s 95 percent African-American.”
Gross
What he doesn’t say is that if you take off your blinders and ignore race, the Shelby County School Board could have located the new high school a couple of miles to the east, and voila, southeast Shelby County isn’t 95 percent any more. In fact, the new county high school would probably be racially balanced enough to impress a federal judge.
But there was no way that the county district was going to move the school east of Hacks Cross Road. If they had done that, they could move some white kids attending school in Collierville to the new high school. And in spite of what some county school officials say, that more eastward location would still be in the Memphis annexation reserve area and therefore, it would meet the criteria of being a school developed jointly by Memphis and Shelby County school systems.
Incredibly enough, the news media continue to accept the county schools’ justifications with an undiscerning eye. As The Commercial Appeal reported without attribution yesterday: “With less than two weeks till the first day of school, some feared the district would have to go back to last year’s grossly overcrowded high schools, leaving the new Southwind High School unused.”
Journalism 101
Apparently, our daily paper relied on the county schools’ version of what’s “grossly overcrowded,” because on balance, the county system doesn’t really have a crisis of overcrowding. As we’ve said before, the county district uses a different formula for determining school capacity, and because of it, its capacity ratings tend to overstate crowding. If Memphis City Schools Superintendent Carol Johnson used the same method of calculating capacities, no school in the city would have been recommended for closure last year.
But misleading calculations aside, the county system sidesteps the question of why they are willing to crowd all of these African-American students into Southwind High School and allow capacities of Germantown schools to drop to levels that suggest that parts of Germantown High School should be shut down.
While it might seem that Judge Donald’s ruling will accelerate the out-migration into neighboring counties, if the county district actually did what she suggests, there would be no schools that are “racially identifiable” as African-American schools (if that’s the sort of thing that motivates you to pack your moving crates in the first place).
When we hear Chairman Pickler say that “my personal opinion is that the ruling, if allowed to stand, would create grave damage to the community,” we’re tempted to say that in the interest of accuracy, The Commercial Appeal should print it like this: “create grave damage to the (white) community.” It’s another craven attempt by the county district to enflame the passions of white parents, and there certainly is nothing in the history of the district to suggest that the black community’s needs and interests ever factor into decisions like attendance zones.
Mapping It Out
You don’t need to be a federal judge to see it. All you need is a map and a magnifying glass. The Southwind High School attendance zone goes directly down Hacks Cross Road, walling off the largely African-American area west of the road. Meanwhile, the Germantown High School attendance zone meanders around like a drunk on Beale Street, seemingly picking up specific subdivisions and houses inhabited largely by white residents.
Looking at the attendance zones, it’s hard to imagine how Shelby County Schools officials can defend them with a straight face. They clearly are set up to keep black kids out of Germantown High School and to make sure white kids do.
As Judge Donald wisely concluded, the burden of proof is on the county district, and it simply failed. While her 62-page opinion sifted through her thinking, all that’s really needed is to consider the arrogance reflected on the attendance zone map.
Five More Years
As we have warned for more than a year, the county board’s decisions on Southwind High School were racially motivated from the beginning. While school officials can beat the drum and chant racial code words like busing and neighborhood schools, this time it will largely fall on deaf ears.
This time around, they’re not trying to intimidate county politicians into silence. They’re trying to pressure a federal judge, and in the end, it’s senseless, self-defeating behavior.
But then again, it’s that kind of behavior that got the board in this position in the first place. Rather than complain about Judge Donald’s decision, the board should take out a map of the district that shows where the students live and without regard to race, draw the attendance zone boundaries.
When you don’t pay attention to race, it’s pretty easy to come up with attendance zones that are more logical, and along the way, they’d be amazed at what they could come up – a district whose schools pass muster in a federal court. As a result of its recent decisions, the district now has five more years to prove that it can manage a district that treats all children fairly and equally.
This could have all been so much simpler.
Monday, July 30, 2007
City School Board On The Verge Of Flunking Key State Test
In response to the post, we were asked by several people what the governor could do.
The answer: Pretty much anything he wants to do.
Warning Shots
That’s because the law gives Governor Phil Bredesen a sweeping array of alternatives, ranging from reduced funding to abolishing the Memphis City Schools Board.
At this point, it’s worth remembering, especially by those who describe the possibility of state takeover of these schools as “draconian,” that Memphis City Schools has had four years to correct problems at these schools.
It’s not as if a warning shot wasn’t ever fired by state government. In fact, shots were fired year after year, and even in the wake of them, state officials feel that Memphis City Schools’ officials are not serious enough about the actions needed to turn around the performance of these schools.
You Say You Want A Revolution
Reports from our district to the state resisting any changes in school leadership or jargon-laden plans that lack any strategic thread are doing nothing in Nashville so much as indicating that the Memphis district wants to appear like it’s taking action without really doing anything too revolutionary.
And yet, the revolution is at hand.
Options For The Gov
As a result of these schools moving from “improvement” to “corrective action,” the governor must pick at least one of the following options:
* He defers programmatic funds or reduce administrative funds
* He institutes and fully implements a new curriculum that is based on state academic standards, including providing appropriate scientifically-based professional development
* He replaces the Memphis City Schools employees who are relevant to the failure to make Adequate Yearly Progress (AYP)
* He removes particular schools from the control of the Memphis City Schools and sets up alternative arrangements for the public governance and supervision of these schools
* He appoints a receiver or trustee in place of the Memphis City School Board
* He abolishes or restructures the entire city district
Take Care
So, in the face of these kinds of pending decisions, how does the Memphis City Schools Board send its most powerful message to Governor Phil Bredesen about their commitment to changing things?
Apparently, by appointing a former school district administrator who’s promised to make no changes and fire no one.
Can you say caretaker?
Sending Messages
The school board seem oblivious to the need to send strong signals from Memphis to state officials about how serious they take the matter of these 17 schools.
One of the worst aspects of serving in stressful public positions in highly-charged environments, and this is especially true of school board members, is that in the midst of the battle, you are often able to convince yourself that what you are doing makes sense and you lose all ability to see how your decisions look to the outside world.
Because school board members now find themselves in the middle of the trees and unable to see the forest, they can’t grasp the common sense of getting help from an independent search firm, of finding an interim superintendent who can be an agent of change who builds on the progress started by Supt. Carol Johnson and of getting businesslike about the public’s business.
And because of it, it appears that the most effective leadership for public education in Memphis this year may well come from 210 miles to the east.
Sunday, July 29, 2007
Old Grievances At Civil Rights Museum Divert Attention From Real Priorities

The current archetype for this tendency is taking place at the National Civil Rights Museum, where, 16 years after being ousted, its former chairman of the board is still warring with those in charge of Memphis’ most nationally known museum.
The fact that it is a one-sided war makes it no less of a distraction for the museum at a time when it should to be dealing with its competitive position in light of a proliferation of African-American heritage museums in the U.S.
Déjà Vu All Over Again
While Circuit Court Judge D’Army Bailey has railed about his rejection as chairman since the 1991 vote, he has a new platform for complaints this year in light of the potential for state government to exercise the option to turn over ownership of the museum to the Lorraine Civil Rights Museum Foundation, whose board has been chaired by civil rights giant Benjamin Hooks since Judge Bailey’s removal.
The foundation has been leasing the museum from the state since groundbreaking for the $8.8 million project in 1987. The museum opened in 1991, and by then, the most dependable facts of life about it were the quality of its exhibits and the rancor that was a regular feature in its board meetings.
In the end, the vote of no confidence for Judge Bailey resulted more from the tone of the meetings and the constant conflict than it did from any fundamental differences of opinion about the future direction of the National Civil Rights Museum.
An Old Conversation
An aspiring actor who’s appeared in several Memphis-based movie productions, Judge Bailey’s script these days suggests that his demise stemmed from a take-over by corporate interests led by local civic leader J.R. Hyde III. Of course, often overlooked in the retelling is the fact that Mr. Hyde only had one vote, and it was a majority of the board that voted to remove Judge Bailey from office.
The vote did nothing to affect Judge Bailey’s board membership, but his immediate resignation from that post eliminated his best platform for have a voice in the life of the museum. Like all of us, Judge Bailey’s strengths are also his weaknesses, and the passion and outspoken opinions that he brings to his civic activities weren’t necessarily the skills needed for an effective board chair.
Repeated today in terms that sound more like control and politics, the complaints by the judge feel more and more stuck in a time warp. In casting the issue as a power struggle for the board, he appeals to populist ideas like reconstituting the board to be dominated by civil rights, labor, African-American legal and legislative members.
Wrong And Wrong
The fact that it’s the wrong question at the wrong time may indicate why it immediately attracted the support of Tennessee Representative Joe Towns Jr., who shares Judge Bailey’s incredulous notion that corporations are dominating decisions about the museum’s future.
The right questions to be asking are the ones facing every African-American heritage museums these days: How do we succeed in an increasingly more competitive world? How do we develop new sources of revenue and get more people to the ticket booth? How do we get into the top tier of museums and attract more corporate and philanthropic support?
It’s as if the critics give the board of directors of the National Civil Rights Museum no credit for the accomplishments over the years: the expansion of the Freedom Awards and the international legends attracted to Memphis to accept it each year, the ability to balance the budget and increase revenues without any state operational funding for 13 years, the designation by USA Today as one of 10 national treasures, one of only three U.S. museums named to the International Coalition of Historic Sites of Conscience, one of only three African-American museums accredited by American Association of Museums and the 12,800-foot expansion of the museum in 2002.
In the parlance of the judge, in this case, the burden of proof rests with the complainant. In the context of similar museums, the record of the National Civil Rights Museum is an object of envy. Several African-American heritage museums and sites have shut down, more have revenue shortfalls that have caused cutbacks in staff and services and even more are saddled with debt and declining attendance.
More Cities Taking The Plunge
And yet, more and more cities – most notably Cincinnati with the $110 million Underground Railroad Museum and Louisville’s $75 million Muhammad Ali Center – have opened major black attractions, and even more are planning huge investments in hopes of grabbing a foothold in African-American tourism.
Atlanta has plans for a $100 million, 100,000 square foot civil rights and human rights center (adjacent to Georgia Aquarium) that will house the papers of Dr. Martin Luther King Jr., bought last year for $32 million by Atlanta leaders; $200 million National Slavery Museum in Fredericksburg, VA; $70 million International African-American Museum in Charleston, SC, and the $500 million Smithsonian National Museum of African-American History and Culture on the Mall in Washington, D.C. Even Nashville is getting into the game with a proposal for a Museum of African-American Music, Art and Culture.
In 1991, when the National Civil Rights Museum opened, it was largely thought in Nashville that it would only be a matter of time before the State of Tennessee would be forced to take over operations of the museum because it was assumed that it would be dependent on state funding to stay open.
Surpassing Expectations
And yet, with only nominal financial support for the Museum from state government (no operating funds for the past 13 years and only $1 million in the 2002 expansion), its board and staff have cultivated private, corporate and philanthropic funding for operating costs and capital investments.
The opening of the National Civil Rights Museum on the site of the assassination of Dr. King was a major reason for the burst of interest in African-American heritage sites. There’s never been a more competitive environment for the National Civil Rights Museum, and because of it, this continuing controversy about 1991 is about more than political theater. More to the point, it has the potential to divert attention from the real priorities of the museum and to damage its national reputation.
Right now, Memphis needs to step up to develop and implement a plan of action that ratifies and strengthens the past success of the museum and defines it as such a nationally unique place that it stays in the top rungs of the nation’s African-American museums.
The Real Question
Today, newer museums are known for their interactive technology, their digital experience and their up-to-date exhibitry. No one can compete with the National Civil Rights Museum on history. But the staff and board understand that the museum also has to live up to visitors’ expectations, and they’re investigating the best ways to do this.
It’s hard to make the case that the present board hasn’t earned the right to make it happen.
Friday, July 27, 2007
This Week On Smart City: FORMing A Creative City
Exploring what it means to be a Creative City has been a regular topic on Smart City. This week we'll visit with Lynda Dorrington who is leading her own creative city movement in Perth, an isolated city on the west coast of Australia. Lynda is executive director of FORM, a craft organization serving Western Australia and the platform from which she has launched a much bigger creative capital initiative.
We'll also talk to Dan Himmelberg, an architect turned workshop leader. His firm, Xpress Ideas, uses innovative methods to gather public opinion to create good design solutions, long range planning and programming. Dan's base is Overland Park, Kansas.
Smart City is a syndicated, weekly hour-long public radio talk show that takes an in-depth look at urban life: the people, places, ideas and trends that affect us all. Host Carol Coletta talks with national and international public policy experts, economists, business leaders, artists, developers, planners and others on the pulse of city life for a penetrating discussion on urban issues.In Memphis,
Smart City is broadcast on WKNO FM, 91.1, at 9 a.m. Sundays. It is also webcast and podcast at the Smart City website, which also has a listing of broadcast times in other cities and the sign up for a weekly newsletter.
Thursday, July 26, 2007
Lantana Projects Plants Seeds For Change

The irony is that vibrancy often stems from small-scale, organic activities like those organized in Memphis by Lantana Projects.
Propelled by the goal of making art appear in surprising places, the group recently unveiled an outdoor art installation by 54-year-old Amsterdam artist Eric Knoote as part of a month-long residency in Memphis.
Surprising Art
“From the Underground Up” was installed on the side of a building at a major downtown intersection, Main and Jefferson, and it features a number of mirrored flowers reflecting outward into the neighborhood.
It seems to symbolize Lantana’s approach to art – taking it to the street, producing “art-based events” rather than “art exhibits.” Recently, its members have even thrown in some “guerilla gardening” as they set out flower plants – what else but lantanas – to beautify previously dreary public space.
From artwork in new condos up for sale to the engaging “emerging artists show” and “Class of ’06” shows, complete with d.j.’s, Lantana is shaking up the way that people look at art. More than 1,000 people attended the “Clas of ‘06” show in two nights. Also, it maintains a lively blog on what’s happening in arts to make it more accessible and ubiquitous in the life of the city.
Working Without A Net
The young organization normally operates without a net – and precious little financial support - and yet, the energy and animation from its events pay big dividends for downtown Memphis.
Founded as a way to connect Memphis with cutting-edge contemporary artists from other countries, Lantana is now creating a virtual community for Memphians, particularly young artists, to talk about ways to achieve their goal of making “Memphis a city of vitality and creativity, and consequently, act as a magnet for talent.”
The international artists residency program remains the centerpiece for the organization, which refuses to yield in its belief that by tapping into international trends, they can also shake up their hometown and make it a leader in contemporary international art.
Music Is Art
She shrugs off suggestions that in a city with a storied music history, it’s hard to find traction for Lantana. “Memphis can embrace its rich cultural history and still embrace contemporary organizations, because they are complementary, not incongruous,” said Elizabeth Lemmonds, Lantana Projects executive director.
These days, Lantana is trying to connect better with the community. “We want to reach out to other organizations and to all sections of the city,” said executive director Elizabeth Lemmonds. “We trying to align with the goals of the Memphis Manifesto Summit and show that art doesn’t have to go only in predictable places.”
That’s why she and her colleagues especially like guerrilla art shows – the kind of art in unexpected places – that’s their passion, she said. “Art doesn’t have to be in a gallery. It doesn’t have to be in a certain place. It can be found when someone turns a corner and bumps into it.”
Looking Beyond Ourselves
She rallies a community of believers who pay attention “to what’s going on in other cities.” “If you say you want to be part of a global community, you need to pay attention to what’s going on in other places,” she said. “And you have to look for opportunities that are good fortune. Someone told us that a friend of his, a Dutch artist (Eric Knoote), was coming to Memphis. We approached him about doing a public project, a lasting piece at a visible downtown corner. It brought the community together. It was community-based and community-backed.”
In talking about what’s important for her organization, she could just as easily be talking about what’s important for cities. “I’m 35-years-old, and I don’t do the same thing that I did as a 21-year-old,” she said. “So, I don’t speak for young people. We need to ask them what they want. If we’re trying to build a legion, it needs to be around what’s important to them. It’s about becoming common ground for a discussion with artists about how we can come together.”
Echoing the recent words of John Seeley Brown in a speech to Leadership Memphis, she adds: “If you want to be a leader, go to the fringes and see the people pushing things forward. They are taking chances. That’s what we have to do, too.”
Wednesday, July 25, 2007
Shelby Farms Park Conservancy Signing Is Time To Celebrate The Power Of The Grassroots
As he once put it, he set out to be one and he’s gotten awfully good at it.
For almost 35 years, he has upbraided mayors, disabused city and county engineers of any notion that they are godlike and lived the life of a pariah at hundreds of public meetings he attended.
Anticipation
But last Friday, he sat in the audience and led the applause as his beloved Shelby Farms Park finally was preserved once and for all for future generations.
It was a long time coming, but the anticipation only made the satisfaction sweeter, he said. The lesson to the rest of us: sometimes it is the rebel, the squeaky wheel and the in-your-face advocate who is a key in making something historic happen.
For him, it all began in 1973 when Shelby County Government announced plans to use a 4,500-acre tract of public land at the heart of the Memphis region for a planned development. The outcry was immediate, and in time, county officials backed down after a firestorm of criticism, saying that the land would be “set aside for public use.”
Public Uses
In the ensuing years, that “public use” included proposals for a zoo, a golf course and conference center, baseball stadium and community college; for selling off some of the land to pay for park development and for running a major highway through the heart of the park. Every time, Mr. Wolff was there leading the opposition, ratcheting up the heat and demanding for the land to be protected.
Today, about 3,000 acres is largely as it was in 1973. About 1,000 acres is being used by Agricenter International, which signed on to the conservancy agreement and maintains control of the area earmarked for agricultural research and as a showcase for innovation.
Sitting in the audience Friday with fellow elderly activists, Ken and Lois Kuiken, Mr. Wolff understood it was a day for dignitaries and speeches. To some in the room, it was also a day to celebrate a fact of life about cities that is too often forgotten – one person can still make a difference.
Emphatic Answers
In what seemed a direct response to questions asked by Mr. Wolff and others since the mid-1970s, Shelby County Mayor A C Wharton said: “Today is about more than the signing of this important conservancy agreement. More to the point, it’s county government’s answers to two questions first asked 34 years ago and every year since.
“Today we deliver two answers: One, Shelby Farms Park is now and forever preserved and protected for all future generations of this county, and two, through this conservancy, Shelby Farms Park will be transformed into one of America’s great urban parks.”
Effective August 1, the newly formed, 34-person Shelby Farms Park Conservancy will take charge of the operations, management and leadership of Shelby Farms Park. The nonprofit group will lead the development of a masterplan of national importance and will raise local and national funding to implement the plan, and it will operate all concessions, set all fees and make all decisions about the parkland. In addition, Shelby County Government agreed to keep its funding at its current level.
History In The Making
Success on the conservancy was a major victory for Mayor Wharton’s style of leadership, the quiet influence of the Hyde Family Foundations on all things Memphis and the grassroots group, Friends of Shelby Farms Park, that morphed from an anti-everything organization into the platform for a new organization, Shelby Farms Park Alliance, that built consensus for the new direction for the park.
An earlier effort – in 2002 – had failed after it turned into a political controversy more related to old political grievances than the merits of the actual proposal. Bruised and beaten, advocates for protecting the park regrouped, developed a new plan of action, recalibrated its message, communicated its vision and slowly and methodically put together a new collaboration of supporters over the past four years.
There were milestones of progress as the pace quickened in recent years. The highly intrusive plans for the highway through the park were scrapped, replaced by the area’s first context sensitive design committee appointed by Mayor Wharton. After about a year of give and take, the committee produced a new road recommendation that balances transportation and environmental concerns.
The Stars Aligned
Building on that momentum, after decades of resisting a conservation easement for the park, county government signaled its interest in an agreement between key players at the park, and an easement was approved last December. The newfound optimism was warranted, because on March 26, the Shelby County Board of Commissioners – led by Commissioner Mike Carpenter – overwhelmingly voted in favor of the conservancy.
First items on the conservancy agenda are to hire someone to lead the master planning process and to hire staff for the new organization. Faced with the opportunity to convert a black canvas of 3,000 acres of parkland into a great urban park, there should be no shortage of interest.
Mayor Wharton said that over the past four years, time and time again, the right person emerged at just the right time to move things ahead. As he spoke, it was hard for us not to think of Laura Adams.
Inching Ahead
Over that time, as progress was often measured in inches, small victories and the change of a word in an official document, she worked skillfully as president of Friends of Shelby Farms Park. Quickly, she became known for her diplomacy, persistence and commitment to success.
In time, her explanations about what could be accomplished at the park were taken up by every one involved, and in time, she convinced her members that there was a better way to succeed than the regular confrontations which had defined the group for decades.
To prove her point, she convinced the members to shift gears and she guided them to a more modulated attitude, reaching for compromise and ultimately, becoming a totally different, more business-oriented organization, the Shelby Farms Park Alliance, where she was named as executive director. That group now disbands and give the Conservancy its support and help.
In truth, she was another contribution that Mr. Wolff made to protect the park. After all, Mrs. Adams is his daughter.
Tuesday, July 24, 2007
A Week in... Memphis: Branding the City from the Inside
Memphis Tourism Foundation is launching its first website in a few days and along with it, a new approach to improving the opinion of Memphians about Memphis.
It’s a total departure, because rather than fall back on the bumper stickers and slogans of most self-image campaigns, the Foundation is asking citizens of Memphis to define the program themselves through their own videos, photographs, music, insiders guides and blogs.
While the Foundation was forming its agenda, Paul O’Connor, executive director of World Business Chicago, agreed to speak in Memphis about city branding. He emphasized that the first audience for any city brand is its own people, who are often much more negative about their city than outsiders.
No Slogans
“Stereotypes come face-to-face with perceptions,” he said. “Branding is hard for a product, and for a city, it’s very, very yard. We see our warts and our problems and we think everyone sees them. Locals are too critical of themselves.”Mr. O’Connor also delivered a warning about cities relying on taglines and slogans when they have not come to grips with their higher purpose.
Because Memphis is only now considering a branding project, the Tourism Foundation decided that in lieu of bumper stickers, it would ask Memphians to offer their own personal opinions.For examples, Memphians are asked to submit a photograph of their city, but not just any photo.
“We’re asking that people send in a photograph that answers one question: If you could only send someone one photograph that represented your Memphis and why you love it, what would it be?” said Calvin Taylor, who is heading up the Foundation as vice-president of its parent organization, Memphis Convention & Visitors Bureau.
Differentiating Memphis
In addition, the Foundation is soliciting short videos from Memphians completing a sentence that begins, “This is my Memphis because…”
To jump start the videos, Christopher Reyes of Live From Memphis and My Memphis TV is sharing his interviews with about three dozen young professionals telling what they like most about the city.
The interviews are featured in a special DVD produced in response to a recommendation of the Memphis Talent Magnet Report, which concluded that if Memphis is to attract 25-34 year-olds successfully, the most convincing stories would be peer-to-peer. The DVD is widely used by Memphis recruiters to sell the city to young workers.
Secrets
In addition, the Foundation website is posting insiders guides to Memphis, starting with “Memphis: It’s More Than You Think.”
In setting a goal to improve the city’s self-image, the website is now recruiting bloggers to write about music, clubs, art and culture and dining, and Memphis’ young professionals organization, MPACT Memphis, is helping out.
To round out its internal image agenda, the Tourism Foundation will soon release a CD to prove that Memphis’ legendary music is not all in its past. Drawing on its healthy live music scene, the foundation has asked some of the city’s leading bands to reinterpret Memphis classic songs as a way of connecting the past to the present.
Buzz-z-z
The Tourism Foundation has set an ambitious agenda in three priority areas - workforce development, internal image and research and advocacy – but its board members have placed a special priority on improving the city’s self-image.
As Mr. Taylor said, “We’ve decided that rather than try to tell our citizens what we think they should feel about Memphis, we want them to tell each other and hopefully create a buzz about the cool, funky aspect of our nature.”
Monday, July 23, 2007
Learning About Cities Through A Microscope

Dr. Aaron Shafer represents the talent that so many cities are concentrated on attracting, but for now, Memphis has him.
He’s a post-doctoral fellow working as a scientist in the labs of St. Jude Children’s Research Hospital, where he’s part of its internationally respected research in molecular immunology.
This much we know in Memphis: St. Jude’s is one of our strongest magnets for talent, attracting hundreds of the smartest scientists in the world to research the molecular and genetic basis for catastrophic diseases in children.
Praying For Change
Because of the post-doc fellows and the internationally known scientists that are drawn to the hospital, more is known these days for its scientific breakthroughs than for its origins in a prayer to the patron saint of lost causes by legendary comedian Danny Thomas.
And yet, Dr. Shafer continues that tradition, too. These days, he’s praying for a skate park in downtown Memphis.
His work on the skate park is a reminder for Memphis as it tries to do better in attracting young professionals: Sometimes, it’s not the mega-project, but the smaller projects – that generate activity and vibrancy – that offer the most immediate returns on investment with this coveted demographic.
Man On A Mission
For seven months, Memphis officials have debated whether to build a new football stadium – at a cost estimated at between $175 and $300 million – while the grassroots campaign mounted by Dr. Shafer and two St. Jude colleagues, Dr. Steve Zatechka and Dr. Zachary Baquet, has been slow to attract official attention at a fraction of the cost – probably about $3 million.
Dr. Shafer is a man on a mission – owing to the childhood example of his father, an Episcopalian minister, and his own interest in helping kids - and he sees the skate park as a place where the spirit of community is strengthened.
When he thinks about Memphis, he draws inspiration from his work with cells. “The complexity of how cells work creates an appreciation for how cities operate,” he said. “Cells are like cities in that what appears to be a series of insignificant collisions and interactions lend themselves to a productive order of things.
Cells And Cities
“To me, it strongly parallels how a city works. Layered in them are checkpoints, and it’s in finding these key events, often obscure, that leads us to understand how a cell works. Similarly, it leads to how a city works.”
Referring to cells as “community-minded entities,” Dr. Shafer said they “respond to external enrichment and never operate by themselves. A successful cell is tightly regulated but at the same time is completely free. When it is no longer regulated, or sensitive to its environment, cancer results. The same happens in cities.”
All of this led Dr. Shafer – a California expatriate who missed the camaraderie of surfing – to see a skate park as more than a place for recreation. To him, it can be the place where people come together, form bonds and strengthen the city itself. Or put another way, it’s a place where seemingly insignificant events have the potential to improve the city itself.
Fighting For An Idea
In support of the skate park, he’s set up a website and regularly blogs on the impact that a park can have on the lives of Memphis youths. “Long-term plans for this facility not only promote Memphis as a recreationally rich city, but to use it as a vehicle for community-building and reconciliation between two cultures,” he writes.
These days, he’s attracting key supporters – Hyde Family Foundations, Riverfront Development Corporation (RDC) and Memphis Division of Parks – and his vision for a skate park in downtown Memphis on the riverfront is picking up steam. Soon, he’s hoping for a feasibility study to be undertaken for the potential site and for a design that would make the park the largest of its kind in the U.S.
Along the way to this point, he’s learned that cells and cities are alike in other ways. Most of all, the same patience and persistence that bring success in the laboratory are needed for anyone who sets out to change things in cities.
17 Schools Risking State Takeover
More about this issue later this week.
Sunday, July 22, 2007
How Walkable Is Your Neighborhood?
This is fun. Get your neighborhood's walkability score here. Just log in with your address. Super simple.
My current Chicago neighborhood scores a 67 out of 100 (no doubt due to too little retail in the immediate vicinity, but plenty within my walking distance -- we're only 17 minutes on foot to Michigan Avenue), but my soon to be neighborhood scores a 93. (One obvious problem with the scoring: Info comes from Google maps which are not always up to date. The Borders across my new location, for instance, is not included in the bookstore listing.)
My downtown Memphis neighborhood scores an 80.
And What Kinds Of Stories Are We Being Told?
“Leadership is about telling stories,” he said to this year’s class of Leadership Memphis.
We were reminded of his advice in light of our past week’s discussion about great mayors, because in his job, Mr. Bergstrom works with one of them, Providence Mayor David Cicilline.
Turn-around
In recent years, Providence has made impressive strides in turning around the city, reducing crime, reforming government, using technology to track public services and more. The Rhode Island Economic Policy Council helps to set the agenda for the city through its work as honest broker of economic development data and as a think tank identifying emerging trends affecting Providence.
“We tell stories using data,” said Mr. Bergstrom, heading up an organization with an uncanny ability to find just the right data to modulate Providence's courses of action. “The right kind of story at the right time can make organizations – and cities – vulnerable to new ideas. Story telling is one of the best ways to change a city.”
In his position, he concentrates on three priorities: 1) improving the business climate, 2) enhancing quality of place, and 3) increasing change for innovation.
Play To Win
But he acknowledges that every city should be working on these goals so they do nothing to differentiate Providence. “These days too many cities play not to lose, rather than playing to win,” he said. We’re figuring out what we need to play and then we figure out what we need to do to win.”
Cities need to take a Wayne Gretzky approach to its economic growth. He said when the ice hockey legend was asked the secret to his success, his answer was, “‘Some skate to where the puck is. I skate to where the puck will be.’ Cities that succeed are skating to where the puck is, and today, that means they are creating an ethos of innovation.”
Like Memphis, Providence faces challenges with the performance of its public schools. “In K-12, the schools are doing exactly what they were designed to do – creating an industrial workforce. The only problem: there is no industrial economy, but we’re still educating graduates for jobs that don’t exist any more.”
Innovate Or Die
That’s why the mantra for cities today is “innovate or face precipitous decline.” He said that Memphis Bioworks Foundation’s success in marrying medical devices with logistics is a well-known national model of innovation.
“Cities that have innovation-ready workers will succeed,” Mr. Bergstrom said. “The end game is for our workers to develop skills so they can offload rules work to free up pattern recognition skills.”
In advice particularly relevant to Memphis, he said that the frontline workers on which the service economy is built must be the focus of innovation strategies. “After all, they are delivering the experience for our customers,” he said.
Immigrants
Because growth of the national economy is being driven by immigration, he said that “The first city to figure out the ways to turn immigrants into knowledge workers win the game. Is there any reason this shouldn’t be Memphis or Providence?”
One potential trouble spot is the “collision course between low literacy Latinos and the innovation economy.”
Another issue of importance is regionalism, because regional answers are needed for the toughest problems facing urban areas. However, he cautions that regionalism is not the magic cure for all that ails cities.
“The beginning of regionalism is not the end of rivalry,” he said. “Rivalry can be good for a region. Regions gain consciousness from outside in. In other worse, Boston will not ‘get’ the region first. Providence will.”
Questions
So, if the theme of Mr. Bergstrom’s message is that leaders tell stories and innovation is the key to whether cities succeed, it leaves us with some deafening questions:
Why are our stories about snakes and sex plots?
Who is best able to tell the kinds of story that can inspire Memphians and promise the
best hope of success for Memphis?
Who understands and is prepared to lead a city of innovation?
Friday, July 20, 2007
State's Tough Talk Bears Schools' Attention
Bereft of positions that don’t seem to spring from a political place, the board is creating the perception that it’s incapable of asking the kind of strategic questions that have to be answered if the district is to build momentum for change.
But they better address them, because more and more, the Bredesen Administration signals that it has no such reticence. In fact, lack of confidence in Nashville that Memphis City Schools can solve its problems has reached the point that one key education official said the progress of the Superintendent Carol Johnson era is “smoke and mirrors.”
Defying Expectations
It seems an unusually harsh assessment, but it does suggest the depths of frustration that state officials have reached in their discussions with the superintendent and her key staff about the 17 schools whose lack of progress over several years opens up the prospect for state takeover.
In particular, state officials assessing the governor’s options are dismayed at Memphis City Schools’ inability to produce some basic reports with the kind of data needed for routine management of a school district. One state official went so far as to say that Carroll County (in rural West Tennessee) does a better job of collecting data about its students, capacities, performance and trends.
“You’d never known that you’re in a major urban school district,” said one person during a recent visit to Memphis before delivering the cruelest cut of all: “We can’t imagine how anybody in leadership in Memphis has been making any kind of informed decisions based on the information that we’ve seen.”
Culture Trumps Strategy Every Day
It’s all a little reminiscent of the consultant who only a few years ago found vital personnel records kept on index cards by Memphis City Schools. Despite some technological improvements, HR polices of the district remain needlessly bureaucratic and unimaginative.
The district can’t seem to get even the simple things right. Case in point: teacher orientation sessions last week started three hours after the announced time and based on reports, it was most notable by its basic ineffectiveness.
Worst of all, most of this information - particularly conversations with state officials - are only slowly finding their way to board members whose grumbling aggravation is replacing the lovefest of only a few weeks ago when Dr. Johnson announced her departure for the green pastures of Boston.
Sending A Message
With board attitudes souring and with state officials asking increasingly hostile questions, it’s beginning to look like Dr. Johnson can’t get to Beantown soon enough. Already, the so-called palace guard is beginning to scatter, seemingly accepting the premise that their futures won’t be as part of Memphis City Schools.
As for Governor Bredesen, he’s given the clearest possible marching orders. He’s not interested in political expediency or in conclusions tempered for public consumptions. It's a message sent unequivocally in a report, as yet uncirculated, shared by the state with the superintendent's office.
Rather, state officials says he’s got a “take no prisoners” attitude about Memphis City Schools, and as a result, rumors swirl in district offices to the extreme, such as the one this week that the governor will soon swoop in and take over the entire district.
Game Of Chicken
While Governor Bredesen has shown that he’s not too far removed from his days as a hard-nosed businessman willing to make the tough calls, it’s hard to imagine that his Department of Education is doing anything to encourage such a comprehensive approach by him. After all, DOE has played games with state regulations for years to stall the inevitability of Memphis City Schools’ lack of progress with the 17 schools.
That said, this much is clear. DOE won’t make the final call; the governor will.
That’s why state officials are frantically investigating options, including the possibility of assigning the management of the schools to the University of Memphis.
Listen Up
So far, Bredesen representatives suspect that the district believes that the state is just rattling its saber and will never take over the 17 schools. At this point, irritable and frustrated by discussions at Memphis City Schools and by requests for information that never comes, state officials are increasingly sending a message not fully comprehended yet on Avery Street.
To the district’s “you’d never do it” attitude, the state is increasing saying: Just try us. The question is whether anybody's listening at Memphis City Schools.
This Week On Smart City: Big Dividends For Big Cities
That's what Portlanders are doing, and it's paying big dividends for their city. Joe Cortright, economist with Impresa Consulting, will tell us about the calculations he's made that produce Portland's Green Dividend.
We'll also find out from Jon Herrmann and Josh Sevin about Philadelphia's comprehensive program to attract top college students...introduce them to the city while in school and hang on to them once they graduate. Jon heads Campus Philly, an organization that promotes active involvement of students with the city's social, civic, and professional communities. Josh is the Manager of Knowledge Industry Initiatives for Philadelphia's Department of Commerce.
Smart City is a syndicated, weekly hour-long public radio talk show that takes an in-depth look at urban life: the people, places, ideas and trends that affect us all. Host Carol Coletta talks with national and international public policy experts, economists, business leaders, artists, developers, planners and others on the pulse of city life for a penetrating discussion on urban issues.In Memphis,
Smart City is broadcast on WKNO FM, 91.1, at 9 a.m. Sundays. It is also webcast and podcast at the Smart City website, which also has a listing of broadcast times in other cities and the sign up for a weekly newsletter.
Thursday, July 19, 2007
Flyer Coverage Wired For Facts
We’re hard-pressed to think of any recent enterprise reporting that’s more impressive than Memphis Flyer reporter Chris Davis’s coverage of Memphis Light, Gas & Water’s troubled investment in Networx.
That he has been given free rein to spend the time to mine the records and connect the dots speaks volumes on the quality of editorial direction at the weekly and should inspire our daily to do more.
But back to Networx, since Mr.
As his coverage points out, there are many questions remaining to be answered if the public is to have any confidence about the recommendations for the sale of MLGW’s stake in the troubled company.
We’re also hoping that he will also ask if anybody at MLGW has thought about the utility turning its share over to City of
If Sidney Shlenker Hadn't Existed, We Might Have Had To Invent Him
We rise in defense of Sidney Shlenker.
Now, we bet that’s something you didn’t ever expect to hear in this city.
We do it because of a comment in the otherwise impressive reporting by Chris Davis of the Memphis Flyer in his coverage of the Networx controversy.
Scapegoat
Big And Bigger
In the end, it wasn’t Mr. Shlenker’s greed that ruined the big plans for The Pyramid. It was city government’s. Once Mayor Dick Hackett convinced Mr. Shlenker that he should add
In the end, he lost everything at the precise moment when it appeared that success was finally at hand. By that time, he and Mr. Tigrett would no longer come to a meeting in City Hall at the same time. Only days after a letter of intent was delivered from French bank Société Générale, agreeing to provide Pyramid financing for the music attraction, the restaurant, the inclinator and the attraction at the apex, the offer was withdrawn when the bankers received a devastating letter from a Memphian whom they would not identify that caused the bank to question and summarily withdraw the loan.
Last Rites
Sitting up in his hospital bed in the
And he did.
A few weeks later, the entire Pyramid plan was as dead as Mr. Shlenker’s chances of being named again as “Man of the Year.”
All of this should serve as a cautionary tale for what strange things can happen when political expediency and civic boosterism converge and give birth to promises that outstrip common sense. It is in such a cauldron that promoters of implausible ideas are treated as saviors of the city by politicians reluctant to conduct basic due diligence for fear of having to abandon the latest magic answer to the problems of
Wednesday, July 18, 2007
Memphis Malaise Prevents Progress Seen In Other Cities
We have a bad case of
The former mayor of
In
Over in
Missing The Boat
In other words,
There’s New York Mayor Mike Bloomberg’s unveiling of the most comprehensive greening plan in the U.S. – 127 separate initiatives aimed at reducing the city’s greenhouse gas emissions by 30 percent by 2030. If that wasn’t enough to keep him busy, he also says he’s going to tackle poverty in the Big Apple.
Boston Mayor Thomas Menino’s takeover of the city’s public schools and the first experiment with pilot schools continue, and inspired by Menino’s success,
Regionalism
Indianapolis Mayor Bart Peterson rolled out a $85 million, multi-pronged crime-fighting plan that builds on his leadership on regional issues. Speaking of regionalism, we’ve previously mentioned Denver Mayor John Hickenlooper’s phenomenal victory at the polls, winning a regional referendum in which voters increased their taxes to pay for 119 miles of new and extended light rail and commuter train lines that cost about $5 billion (not to mention his victory with a referendum for $378 million jail bond issue).
If there’s any single issue that best exemplifies
Cities like
E-Government
Digital technology is being used widely in other cities to reinvent government services, but here, our local governments can’t even give us websites that are usable or useful, much less offer serious e-government programs.
Wi-fi plans proliferate in more than 300 cities, but not in
Most of all, it brings a data-driven approach to government administration that in time changes the culture itself through budgets based on performance measurements. Budgeting for results seems like a pretty straightforward concept, but legislators often resist it because they rightly conclude that the measurements could just as easily be used to hold them accountable.
Knowledge Is PowerAs former Martin O’Malley – now governor of
All in all, there is a widespread lack of understanding in government about how data can be used to drive important decisions, and normally, its implementation is driven by a single disciple elected to the mayor’s office. As a result, it’s unlikely to become part of our city government anytime soon, but hopefully, it will at least become a topic for the campaign trail.
Data And More Data
No one in public offices seems to grasp the potential of a data-driven government as much as Mayor Bloomberg. But then again, he made billions by creating a company based on real-time data.
Each new
A final lesson to be learned from Mayor Bloomberg is an emphasis on hiring the smartest people and letting them do their jobs. His directive to one newly appointed manager: “It’s your agency. Don’t screw it up.” We wonder the last time any city director heard that from Mayor Herenton.