Tuesday, December 23, 2008

Memphis Must Leap Frog Into The Future

The Memphis economy has reached the moment of truth.

Languishing in the lower rungs of the economic indicators that matter, we have reached the point where we either snap out of it or we sink into the abyss with Detroit and Cleveland.

It's that serious, and the choices are that stark. In the family of cities today, the rich get richer and the poor get poorer. It doesn't take a Harvard University economist to point out which group we are in.

Leaping Ahead

Today, cities that are successful are becoming ever more so, gaining momentum, attracting talent and gaining knowledge economy jobs. Likewise, cities that are floundering are failing behind at a quickened pace, lacking the kind of leadership that can pull them out of the downward spiral, reject their reliance on low-wage, low-skill jobs and adopt strategies that have the potential to shake off the civic lethargy and to set them on a dramatic course for the future.

It's not going to be easy for the cities that are floundering. In other words, it's not going to be easy for Memphis.

We have no margin for error, and we have to start doing things right. Really right. Right now.

To have any chance at all, cities like ours need leap frog strategies that catapult them ahead of rival cities. In Memphis' case, it would take a major leap forward just to get to the median in most economic indicators, but that would be a start.

Seeing A New Future

Mary Jo Waits – a guest on Smart City and someone who pioneered these kinds of strategies for Phoenix and State of Arizona – explained the leapfrog approach this way:

"The principles are straightforward, whether for companies or communities. It's a one-two punch: Spot opportunity and respond faster and better than anyone else. Remember when Steve Jobs and Apple challenged IBM? They didn't do it by catching up, by building a better mainframe.

"They did it by seeing a different future, betting on the personal computer and leapfrogging over IBM. It works for regions, too. Austin and San Diego leapfrogged over most U.S. metropolitan areas by capturing more talent, research funds and science- and technology-oriented jobs in a relatively short period, less than a decade.

Take Your Best Shot

"Not entirely. Mostly, leapfroggers pick their shots. Sometimes, the best shot is to play at the edges, aiming to set the pace of innovation. And sometimes, in this economic whirlwind, the best shot is to follow the 'first mover.' Appropriating an idea that is already working in the world can produce the quickest results.

"Ray Kroc didn't invent McDonald's; he took the idea from brothers Dick and Maurice McDonald when he bought their small chain of burger joints. And Home Depot founders Arthur Blank and Bernie Marcus didn't invent the first warehouse-outlet hardware chain. They got the 'big box' concept from their earlier employer, Handy Dan Home Improvement.

"But copying a good idea is not enough. You have to make the idea your own, grafting it onto your situation. And you have to improve on it so that your competitive position takes a big leap forward, as do the benefits it offers. Leapfrog players pursue with single-minded focus big jumps in performance."

Improving ED

That in a nutshell is the challenge facing MemphisED, the economic growth part of Memphis Fast Forward, and all the rest of us.

We'll know we're on the right track when we quit talking about distribution as the Holy Grail and start talking about entrepreneurship and innovation. We'll know we're succeeding when we quit giving away tax freezes for marginal industries that do nothing to improve job opportunities or job skills for our workers. We'll know we're on the right track when we yank down all the "America's Distribution Center" signs that remind every visitor that we have set such low expectations for ourselves.

As a result, there's no time like the present to dream big dreams. Pursuing the same old industry anchors is risky if the ultimate aim is to transform Memphis into a strong competitive position for today's talented workers – whose presence in turn attracts new jobs.

In fact, if you want to predict our success in the future, throw away all the statistics and graphs. There's only one indicator that we really need to watch – the percentage of Memphians who have college degrees. There's no more accurate proxy for future success than this.

Flunking Out

Unfortunately, Memphis is near the bottom of the top 50 U.S. cities in the percentage of college graduates and near the bottom in the percentage of young people in college. In other words, we can sift through dozens and dozens of strategies, but at the end of it all, every one of our programs need to aim at doing one thing – increasing the percentage of college-educated workers in Memphis. Absent a change in those numbers, Memphis' future is sealed.

Meanwhile, some people in local government believe that MemphisED aims too low in the number of new jobs it hopes to create in five years – 50,000. For one thing, that number is essentially what Memphis' economy was generating 15 years ago, so it has a certain "back to the future" feel to it. Secondly, it's not about the number of jobs but where the jobs are being created, because the success of our economic growth plans will be judged fundamentally on creation of jobs in sectors that pay higher wages and elevate our city to compete in the new economy.

Most of all, we need to become a city where people choose to live and work. That's the toughest challenge of all, because it requires a wholesale shift in our mindset about who we are and who we can become. But in the end, that's the task ahead, because if we don't accept it now, we have preordained Memphis' future as a failing city.

Tomorrow's Post: Learning From the Past


Anonymous said...

Right, more PILOT's!! What a dead idea!!

Anonymous said...

Politically, there will be no leadership on these issues until Mayor Herenton is gone. Even his biggest fans would have to agree that he's running on fumes now, as far as moving Memphis forward. So that's two more years or, likely, a little less. I do believe A C Wharton could open the windows at City Hall and finally get some fresh air circulating there. The best way for political leadership to help the economy get moving is mostly by staying out of the way. But it can do a LOT toward making the city itself more pleasant -- everything from improving parks and greenways to making sure junked lots get cleared.

Economically, it's going to be tough for a year or so. We can't rely on Fredex for everything. The medical center additions hold the most obvious promise for a distinctive, high-paying industry, and they'll be finishing those new buildings about the time the economy gets back in gear.

I once saw an urban plan drawing, maybe on this site, for the medical district. It envisioned a coordinated streetscape for that whole area ... similarly-designed street lamps, sidewalks, streets made into boulevards. There's next to nothing else for blocks and blocks other than medically-related buildings there now, and the whole plan could be accomplished for relatively little money. Definitely worth it, as an entrance to downtown Memphis if nothing else.

Any word on the status of the Graceland/Elvis Presley Blvd improvements? Just improving the looks of that corridor alone would go a long way to improve hometown pride for both sides of the race divide.

Anonymous said...

I wouldn't be completely surprised if the state moved UTCHS to Knoxville; Memphis' political power in the legislature is waning, and the half of the local reps from here are only interested in grandstanding (Brian Kelsey) or fighting the grand moral battle of abortion. Why not just have the state abandon this city entirely?

Anonymous said...

They already have and we need all the stats we can garner and glean, college grads are neither a magic pill nor an indicator of success that we will likely see.

Anonymous said...

The "BIG jumps in performance" you are writing about are called nonlinear and they require great understanding about things Memphians don't like to think about.
They require knowing who we are and we desperately don't want to do that because the truth here is particularly more ugly than can be admitted without appropriate sentencing afterward. Sorry.
We've waited so long to look into the mirror that we have become the monster that we fear, no joking.
The atrocities committed by leadership in Memphis are on such a scale that they need to have their fortunes rendered worthless and liquidated before they are "led off".
What you have here is a cultivated population of people too scared or weak to speak truth to power and/or get up and do something about leadership here in fear of government enabled retribution by power and a second cultivated population of criminals who can do nothing but substantiate getting loads of federal money to politician's pockets through disjointed "improvement" schemes that bill but never produce positive results.
You've even let them con you into tying civil services into their system/information database to intimidate citizens if not drive them broke via those same services. Do something someone in power doesn't like and your MLGW bill goes super-high suddenly and no number of trips to customer service will alleviate it.
In this country, America, we used to remove people from office who behaved like that BY FORCE.
Then we tried them and evidence put them in the clink. You have too many inappropriate rules about how you can get what evidence and then they return to work to burn and shred.
You want people to move here and make it great, you're gonna have to remove the entrenched thugs running this place. They are your most public of public figures and their backroom city council chronies. You know, there was a lot of info on city council candidates and a lot of them were obviously not obeying the laws. Many had not paid their property taxes for quite some time, others had done worse. Their candidacies should have been impeached since that is the law here.

Anonymous said...

Its really nice information
thanks for this great link

Entertainment at one stop