Sunday, November 22, 2009

Thawing Out The Logic About Tax Freezes


At the risk of being burned at the stake for heresy, we just have to say it: we don’t care if warehouses are moving from Memphis to Mississippi.

And while we’re at it, let’s be honest about one more thing: tax freezes are more about land development than economic development.

But as long as our economic development officials measure success by giving tax waivers rather than limiting them, we’ll continue to chase distribution jobs and pretend that they somehow are positioning Memphis to succeed in a knowledge economy.

As long as we talk the talk about the power of a regional economy and but can’t walk the walk, our obsession with North Mississippi will continue to erode a healthy, balanced economic development strategy.

It’s An Entitlement

Maybe, just maybe, North Mississippi is luring the kinds of companies we shouldn’t really worry about, because the vast majority of employers who are still here are the value-added kinds – those that pay good salaries for good jobs.

And maybe, just maybe, we should be focused on keeping people, and it starts by doing a better job of explaining that taxes in North Mississippi are higher than taxes in many parts of Shelby County. Perhaps, we should let Mississippi pay for the infrastructure that distribution facilities want and we should do our best to keep the people who work there.

But that’s not what we do and because of it, to this day, no one has adequately explained why over a 10-year period, Memphis and Shelby County approved more than half of the state’s tax freezes – 809 of them – while Nashville approved only five. Or put another way, Memphis approved more tax freezes than Nashville, Chattanooga, Jackson and Knoxville combined.

A former director of the Nashville mayor’s office of economic and community development put it best: “Incentives should incentivize. Once it becomes an entitlement, it’s no longer an incentive.” It’s easy enough to know which noun applies to tax incentives here.

Why Do We Fight For Them?

For 15 years, it’s been real estate development interests that have driven the lobbying that turned tax freezes into entitlements, and they took them to the point that warehouses may never again pay taxes in this city. It is sobering to drive down Shelby Drive and Holmes Road in Southeast Shelby County and realize that a handful of the hundreds of warehouses covering the landscape are paying property taxes.

It almost defies logic. If a company doesn’t understand the added competitive power that comes from being in the world headquarters of FedEx, perhaps they’re simply too stupid to care about in the first place.

But if we don’t give taxes away, we’re told we’ll lose the “logistics business” to Fayette County or DeSoto County. The key question regarding warehouses is this: why should Memphis taxpayers care where they locate? If they locate in Shelby County and get tax freezes, it just perpetuates the disproportionate share of local property taxes being paid by homeowners and small businesses.

Years ago, city and county governments hired a firm to analyze land use and taxes. After inputting the data, he called officials to say that he could not deliver the final report on time because his computer malfunctioned. He was given extra time.

Error Message

A few weeks later, he called again. He reported that the computer hadn’t malfunctioned after all. Because so many large swaths of property were off the tax rolls – particularly mile after mile of warehouses in South Shelby County – the computer “thought” that the data must be faulty and sent an error message. Shelby County was not similar to what was normally found in other metros like ours.

As syndicated columnist on urban affairs Neal Peirce has written: “Call it, if you will, the crack cocaine of state and local governments’ economic development practices -- their endless flow of tax breaks and outright gifts to private corporations they either want to land, or figure they have to pay off to stay put.”

Today the practice runs so deep, pervading such a huge number of corporate location moves, that officials -- even those who privately admit it’s an insane, zero-sum system -- keep on forking out the cash, no matter how incredibly costly the addiction. For years Greg LeRoy has been America’s chief whistle blower on the subsidies, which he estimates add up nationally to $50 billion a year.

So what should be done? First, says Mr. LeRoy, “disclosure-disclosure-disclosure.” When the public is informed, the jobs blackmail diminishes. As we have frequently said, this begins by posting every tax freeze on the city and county websites. Then set up serious “clawback” recapture provisions when a subsidized firm doesn’t fulfill its job-producing promises. And stop all subsidies for retail deals, except in truly-depressed inner-city neighborhoods.

Reinvestment Needed

And, let governments, Mr. LeRoy proposes, start registering and regulating the site location consultants who make often negotiate the public subsidies. This would stop them from double-dealing (and driving up subsidy costs) by requiring that they take payment from just one party to any transaction.

But the really fresh ground LeRoy plows is a big reminder to us that the scramble for jobs that ignited the subsidy wars will soon be pointless -- and simply unaffordable. With baby-boomers headed toward retirement, we’re likely to face an enormous shortage of skilled workers. From 1980 to 2000, the pool of prime-age (25-to-54-year old) workers increased by 35 million. But from 2000 to 2020, the expansion will be just 3 million. Teachers, nurses, expert workers of all sorts will be in desperately short supply. Huge new efforts (and spending) for workforce development will be critical to stop a slide in the United States’ standard of living.

At the same time, America’s physical plant is suffering from serious disinvestment and deterioration. Traffic congestion is costing our economy $67.5 billion a year; thousands of bridges need replacement; wastewater systems are in bad shape; almost 2,600 dams are now deemed unsafe; transit spending is far below what’s needed to maintain even the inadequate systems we now have. The American Society of Civil Engineers totals the repair bill at $1.6 trillion. Discount that 50 percent and the pending bills are still staggering.

The bottom line, says Mr. LeRoy: “We need reinvestment, not disinvestment.” It’s time, he asserts, to take a “fine-tooth comb” to the $50 billion states and cities are now spending for corporate promises of jobs. Any subsidy that doesn’t serve compelling public need by creating more skilled labor, or doesn’t provide a “carrot” for companies to invest in new skills development, should go on a list for likely elimination.

It’s time, Mr. LeRoy concludes (as if speaking for Memphis taxpayers), for sweeping reform of the subsidy policies and to recognize them for what they are: “wasteful handouts we can no longer afford.”

24 comments:

Anonymous said...

Amen on this one.

balunov23 said...

Good post, useful information. Thanks for share.

Suzanne Allen said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Suzanne Allen said...

I agree 100% with this analysis.

Anonymous said...

This is good food for thought. Basically you are saying that maybe Shelby should concentrate on white collar jobs and let the blue collar ones go to Desoto county. I have no problem with that.

My main problem is the cost of infrastructure, primarily the International Airport, paid for by Memphis and Shelby County. would there be some way to require a larger cost of contribution for those MS warehoused goods shipping out than thsoe from TN, a surcharge so to speak?

And yes, we are controlled too much by real estate interests, a large part due to the topography of Shelby county versus the hilly topography of the other cities in TN, preventing such devleopment. It has dominated our politics more than most people realize.

It was a driving force behind Joe Ford's selection to be interim mayor and will be a driving force in next year's county elections.

Midtowner said...

I too agree that we hand out the tax breaks like candy.

But let's be consistent. Memphis doesn't ... yet ... hand out tax breaks along the Trolley line for TOD development like other cities do. Let's keep it that way ...

Zippy the giver said...

We don't talk the talk ALL the time, half the time we say stuff like "we'll do it Memphis' way", "Memphis and Memphians first", and other such phrases, publicly, and THAT is how we act, that's our true walk, with some insincere doublespeak.
The very cultural phenomenon that caused th other problems here, a basic weird stingy selfishness when it comes to anyone else on a deep level.

wholesale watches said...

wholesale watches
uggs outlet
cheap-ugg-boots
Dwight Howard shoes
nike shoes
Cartier watches
Tracy McGrady shoes
Jason Kidd Shoes

Anonymous said...

Good Walking Shoes for Problem Feet. mbt shoes** Foot problems can be indicators walking shoes** of more serious health issues. mbt** Shoe companies holding a mbt schuhe** seal of approval from the American cheap mbt shoes** Podiatric Medical Association (APMA) swiss shoes** are noted to contribute to proper foot health for barefoot shoes** people suffering from foot conditions. mtb shoes ** Proper walking shoes have preventative and anti shoes** corrective measures, including proper support mbt sale** and cushioning for ankles, soles and heels. masai** Proper Walking Techniques:A walker's foot masai shoes** hits heel first and should roll off the heel upward. posture shoes** Low supportive heels that are mbt shoes clearance** rounded are best to help you walk mbt walking shoes** properly and will reduce conditions with feet, joints and legs. mbt footwear** Rockport Walker:Rockport styles are mbt outlet** highly noted by the APMA Seal of Acceptance. mbt shoes sale** Rockport shoes provide comfort in discount mbt shoes** support of standing and walking for long periods of time. mbt chapa shoes** The soles are stiff and the mbt m.walk shoes** shoe isn't considered very stylish, mbt tataga shoes** but the design is consistent with good foot health. mbt barabara shoes** Birkenstock Sandals:Limited to the summer months, mbt sport 1** the Birkenstock sandal is one of mbt sport 2** the most popular walking-shoe styles. mbt tembea shoes** The shoe offers styles for mbt lami shoes** men and women. MBT Shoes: Masai mbt changa shoes** Barefoot Technology shoes have no heel; mbt beach shoes** they force you to roll from heel to mbt tunisha shoes** foot with each step, which is the proper mbt safiri shoes** walking technique. The shoe is heavy and takes getting used to, but is mbt maliza shoes** recommended as a solution for problem feet.

Knox Karter said...

This is a great inspiring .I am pretty much pleased with your good work. You put really very helpful information. I am looking to reading your next post.

Research and Development Logo

Knox Karter said...

Your blog is really excellent. It inspires the readers who have that great desire to lead a better and happier life. Thanks for sharing this information and hope to read more from you. Great information

Ready-Made Logo

Coupon Blues said...

Nice and fantastic post. thank you very much to do this for us and thanks for sharing this with us. Amazon Promo Codes
American Eagle Promo Code
AutoZone Coupons
Barnes & Noble Coupon Code
Barneys Warehouse Coupons
bebe Coupon Codes
Bed Bath and Beyond Coupon
Best Buy Coupons
Bluefly Coupon Codes
Groupon Promo Codes
Haggar Coupons
JcPenney Coupons
Kohls Coupons
Light In The Box Coupons
Macy's Coupon
Next Day Flyers Coupon Codes
Overstock Promo Codes
Sears Coupons
SmartBargains Coupons
Target Promo Codes
Walmart Coupon Codes
Woot Coupon Codes

Edi said...

Untuk mendapatkan kemenangan pada permainan Ceme Keliling dengan lebih mudah, segera mainkan dengan menggunakan Aplikasi Hack Judi Ceme Keliling.

Situs Judi Bandar Poker Agen itu99
LiveChat Judi Agen Casino ituGol
Hack AduQ ituGol
Tips Bermain Casino Online IndoWinBola
Situs DominoQQ Agen IndoWinBola
Situs Bola Mix Parlay Terpercaya
Agen Judi Win Rate Tertinggi
Deposit Modal Kecil Menang Besar

Keddy said...

Thanks for your post.

Welcome to “Chanchal Security Service", it is our GREAT pleasure to introduce ourselves as one of the Best Security guard service in Gurugram.

Security Guard Service in Gurugram

Maarc said...

Nice Information

Innovation Security Force has been one of the finest company who provides you the best Security Services in Delhi with an affordable prices.

Security Services in Delhi

Edi said...

Ingin memainkan judi online dan mendapatkan keuntungan banyak segera dapatkan infonya melalui website yang tersedia dibawah ini.

Situs Judi Sakong Online itu99
Trik Menang Judi Togel ituGol
Trik jitu Menang Casino IndoWinBola
Situs Roulette Online QBet99

Dapatkan kemenangan mudah pada permainan Judi Online dengan menggunakan aplikasi hack yang tersedia diwebsite Cheat Pasti yang tersedia dibawah ini.

Hack Game Casino Online

Nonton Video Panas Dan Baca Cerita Dewasa hanya diwebsite Situs Panas yang tersedia dibawah ini.

Ngseks Dengan Mama Dan Mbakku
Ngseks Dengan Pasien Dirumah Sakit
Ngentot Dipemandian Air Panas

Keddy said...

Best Home Packers and Movers Balewadi aim to provide personally hand free packing and moving services to its customers. Best Home Packers and Movers in Balewadi are committed to providing our clients safe moving, during handling, loading and unloading, and transportation.

Escort Call Girl Gurgaon said...

Are you looking for gurgaon call girls available in top rates hotels on single call. Book sexy call girls in gurgaon for any details, visit link: https://www.escortcallgirlgurgaon.com/gurgaon-call-girls-price-list

Ankit Ron said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
India Real Estate said...

2 BHK Flat In Kondapur Hyderabad

Ankit Ron said...

very nice your post thank you
new fantasy app
new fantasy cricket app

Simran Sharma said...



park circus escorts
park circus escort

Harry said...

We are providing the world best service if you want to look for high-quality logo designs to visit our site. 75% off logo design buy

Royal Model said...


kolkata call girl sex
kolkata hot girls